Wasn't this cereal shaped like little milk bottles? I remember something like that from a long time ago.

Oh my gosh, oh my gosh, oh my gosh...this has plagued me for *literally* over 25 years...I ate this as a child (maybe 5 or 6 years old?) and I could never remember what the heck they were called. I have asked at least a hundred people over the years if they knew what they were, and no one had a clue. They must have made quite an impact on my taste buds as a child, because it has been on my mind for years!!! I never thought about looking online for an answer...but my husband and I were listening to a radio show today about "things that have been driving you nuts"-a forum where you ask a question and listeners can call in and tell you what you want to know (hopefully). I told my him I wanted to call in and ask about it and he said I was nuts, that there was no cereal like that. HAHA!! The only things I could remember were a) I loved them b) There was a milkman involved in some way on the box and c) They were shaped like an elongated cheerio with a little line through the center. (I could be a bit off on this) Wow. What a gem I've found here, I was not hallucinating. Thanks!!!!!

YES!!!!! Finally, an answer to my life long query. I am 30 years old and no one else remembers this cereal. Not even my older sister. All I remembered was a milkman and the shape was kind of like a long thing with a line down the middle. I just remember thinking it was the best thing I ever ate. I am so happy to know what the heck it is. Now...if I can only get my hands on some.

Thank you, thank you!!!!!! Like the other commentors, I too LOVED this cereal as a child (I am 31) and could not remember the name, just that there was a milkman on a blue box. Thank you for the help, I am now going to search for the maker to see if it is still made in limited quantities.

OMG, OMG OMG! I have been racking my brain for years(I'm 33 now)trying to remember what the name of this cereal was! I LOVED it so much and although I couldn't remember the taste, I could remember what it was shaped like! Thank you so very much for jogging my brain.

I am so grateful for the internet... I have just recently eaten Kashi honey wheat O's and they reminded me of Graham Crack-o's, but I couldn't remember what they were called..... so if anyone misses that cereal, I suggest giving the Kashi cereal a try but make sure it's Honey Wheat O's, not any other variety

Like all of you I'm 30+ and graham crack-O's is my all time favorite cereal! I believe they replaced this cereal with Cracklin' Oat Bran. It's good, but no where close to Graham crack-O's(The best cereal ever made). We should petition for this cereal to be reintroduced. I guarantee it will bring out the kid in every 30+ cereal lover! My taste buds have been deprived for over 20 years

I loved this cereal. I hated that they got rid of it because there isn't another graham cereal that tastes even close to it! I was very dissapointed trying them all out! I wish they would bring it back because I swear I would eat it every day!!!

I couldn't remember the name of this cereal either. I'm glad someone described what the cereal looked like, because that's all I could remember. I'd forgotten about the milkman on the box. Now I'm gonna ask my brother & sister if they remember it.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pPwD8PEveto Here is the commercial

I loved it too (I'm 33), but I wonder if it's as good as we remember. When I was five I also liked vanilla icing with cucumbers and wanted to marry my brother.

This is hilarious! I'm 32 and I also loved this cereal! I still think I remember the taste.

I remember this well. (Im 40).....shape of ceral was a milk bottle.

YES YES!!! I remember this cereal too!! It was so good. It held the milk inside ther cereal and was sooooooo good. I remember it was called Milkman or something like that. I ALSO remember the taste....mmmmm. By the way I am 34. Good times